OT: Did Dallas get robbed?

[bigbadjohn45]

At first glance, I was sure he caught it, but the replay did confirm that the ball hit the ground, and, by rule, was an incompletion. That was one of the biggest call reversals I've ever witnessed.

Your thoughts?

 

[blueboro007]

Karma.

 

[C-Bow]

By rule it was not a catch, so no, they did not get robbed.

And yeah, karma.
Posted from Rivals Mobile

 

[MTFNBY5]

Rule, as written, is too technical - The pass was completed, the player made three or four normal FB moves after catching the ball and his knee was down before losing control of the ball BUT, according to the rule is an incompletion.

Rule needs to be changed - Stupid

 

[TeKEraider]

Rule sucks not the call. Definitely karma. A week after screwing the Lions they get done in by what is commonly referred to as the Calvin Johnson Rule. Perfect.

 

[Predarat]

They robbed then got robbed. Though that was a catch, that rule is awful and needs to be change.

 

[bigbadjohn45]

Originally posted by Predarat:
They robbed then got robbed. Though that was a catch, that rule is awful and needs to be change.

Yes, I agree that it was a catch. Crappy rule that needs changing. And I was rooting for Green Bay and still think he caught it!