Many of you have spoke to this, but it truly deserves its own thread. Our Middle Tennessee State University Blue Raiders are the direct result of a failed culture.
It started all the way back in 1999 when the idea of MTSU going D1 was going to be enough to spark additional interest in the program. There is nothing no doubt Boots Donnelly did great things for the D1-AA Raiders, but we had not won a conference title since 1992.
It had been 7 years and Middle was trending downward. We took a shot on Coach Mac and in 2001 we looked like geniuses, co-champs with the future looking even better. We were making NATIONAL NEWS with a Heisman Candidate in Dwone Hicks (Hicks 4 Heisman).
Despite the success the city was never behind MT. Then comes the great crash of 2002. Staring the season 0-5 with a loss to Southeast Missouri State. By the end of the season the stands were EMPTY.
Fast forward to 2006 and we're co-champs again, having lost to Troy at home. We go bowling and get crushed, entirely outclassed by the MAC. That's alright though, as our future is once again bright.
2007: Start the season off 0-4 and blow a chance at a statement win v. UVA., End the year 5-7, needing to only beat ULL in Murfreesboro to contend for a bowl game.
2008: Start season 1-4, with the lone win being v. UMD... Still find a way to go 5-7
2009: 10-3, but per usual, co-champions, having lost to Troy. We get our chance to shine at home v. Mississippi State but get bowled over. We're back on the path though, 10-3! Bowl Game Win, and our team is coming back for a great campaign in 2010.
2010: 6-7 with a loss to Miami (OH) in the GoDaddy.Com bowl. Attendance drops to 10K. All momentum form 2009 is lost, and we look like a team who just go lucky.
2011: 2-10. 2009 is proven to be a fluke.
2012: 8-4: but third place in the Sun Belt. Did i mention that we lost to McNese State to start this season? Did I also mention that we beat Georgia Tech and Memphis on the road in back-to-back games. A true Jekyll and Hyde season.
2013: First season in CUSA and were 8-4. We get crushed by Navy in a bowl game, still 8-5 is a great sign for the future
2014: 6-6. We are now losing to Memphis and UTEP.
2015: 7-6 with a loss in the Bahama Bowl. So much for momentum.
2016: 8-5 including a bowl out loss in the Hawaii Bowl. We're no longer competing with Vanderbilt.
2017: 7-6 with a stinker v. Vandy @ home but a win over Syracuse on the road. But hey! we won a bowl game v. Arkansas State!!!
2018: Ok senior year for Brent, Big things are happening.... We won the CUSA east title, and are playing at home v. UAB, who we just beat a week prior. NOPE! We blow that. We got the NOLA bowl though, time to make an impact.... NOPE! we get blown away. 8-6.
What the fans, players, and administration have seen is the same story year to year. We have no ability to play at a level of consistency that invites players or fans to invest in the program. MTSU will have its moment in the sun to be followed up with a total garbage performance.
What this program lacks is pride. An attitude that says we are not going to 'compete' but we are going to 'win' Fans are tired of being right about little Middle when it comes to their money. Why spend money to be disappointed anymore?
A culture of winning has never been established at Middle. What we have established is a culture of "MEH" and MEH doesn't bring out fans, and it doesn't excite recruits to come here and play. Every year we have a chance to build something, we drop down to MEH-dle Tennessee State University.
How do we fix this? I'd say we start with a coach whose fired up to fight the big guys, not one who simply wants to compete. Maybe we get kids who are here to play football and not simply graduate with their coaching football degree. Its been a decade and nobody has seen a fired up Rick Stockstill, maybe it is time for a change now that Brent is gone.
Whatever is the answer, it starts with one thing: CULTURE. A winning culture needs to be established here... One that wins the games it should and continually reaches for something better than conference co-champs.
Look at franchises like the NY Yankees, St. Louis Cardinals, Pittsburgh Steelers, New England Patriots, these guys win consistently because its expected. And simply 'competing' is beneath them.
It started all the way back in 1999 when the idea of MTSU going D1 was going to be enough to spark additional interest in the program. There is nothing no doubt Boots Donnelly did great things for the D1-AA Raiders, but we had not won a conference title since 1992.
It had been 7 years and Middle was trending downward. We took a shot on Coach Mac and in 2001 we looked like geniuses, co-champs with the future looking even better. We were making NATIONAL NEWS with a Heisman Candidate in Dwone Hicks (Hicks 4 Heisman).
Despite the success the city was never behind MT. Then comes the great crash of 2002. Staring the season 0-5 with a loss to Southeast Missouri State. By the end of the season the stands were EMPTY.
Fast forward to 2006 and we're co-champs again, having lost to Troy at home. We go bowling and get crushed, entirely outclassed by the MAC. That's alright though, as our future is once again bright.
2007: Start the season off 0-4 and blow a chance at a statement win v. UVA., End the year 5-7, needing to only beat ULL in Murfreesboro to contend for a bowl game.
2008: Start season 1-4, with the lone win being v. UMD... Still find a way to go 5-7
2009: 10-3, but per usual, co-champions, having lost to Troy. We get our chance to shine at home v. Mississippi State but get bowled over. We're back on the path though, 10-3! Bowl Game Win, and our team is coming back for a great campaign in 2010.
2010: 6-7 with a loss to Miami (OH) in the GoDaddy.Com bowl. Attendance drops to 10K. All momentum form 2009 is lost, and we look like a team who just go lucky.
2011: 2-10. 2009 is proven to be a fluke.
2012: 8-4: but third place in the Sun Belt. Did i mention that we lost to McNese State to start this season? Did I also mention that we beat Georgia Tech and Memphis on the road in back-to-back games. A true Jekyll and Hyde season.
2013: First season in CUSA and were 8-4. We get crushed by Navy in a bowl game, still 8-5 is a great sign for the future
2014: 6-6. We are now losing to Memphis and UTEP.
2015: 7-6 with a loss in the Bahama Bowl. So much for momentum.
2016: 8-5 including a bowl out loss in the Hawaii Bowl. We're no longer competing with Vanderbilt.
2017: 7-6 with a stinker v. Vandy @ home but a win over Syracuse on the road. But hey! we won a bowl game v. Arkansas State!!!
2018: Ok senior year for Brent, Big things are happening.... We won the CUSA east title, and are playing at home v. UAB, who we just beat a week prior. NOPE! We blow that. We got the NOLA bowl though, time to make an impact.... NOPE! we get blown away. 8-6.
What the fans, players, and administration have seen is the same story year to year. We have no ability to play at a level of consistency that invites players or fans to invest in the program. MTSU will have its moment in the sun to be followed up with a total garbage performance.
What this program lacks is pride. An attitude that says we are not going to 'compete' but we are going to 'win' Fans are tired of being right about little Middle when it comes to their money. Why spend money to be disappointed anymore?
A culture of winning has never been established at Middle. What we have established is a culture of "MEH" and MEH doesn't bring out fans, and it doesn't excite recruits to come here and play. Every year we have a chance to build something, we drop down to MEH-dle Tennessee State University.
How do we fix this? I'd say we start with a coach whose fired up to fight the big guys, not one who simply wants to compete. Maybe we get kids who are here to play football and not simply graduate with their coaching football degree. Its been a decade and nobody has seen a fired up Rick Stockstill, maybe it is time for a change now that Brent is gone.
Whatever is the answer, it starts with one thing: CULTURE. A winning culture needs to be established here... One that wins the games it should and continually reaches for something better than conference co-champs.
Look at franchises like the NY Yankees, St. Louis Cardinals, Pittsburgh Steelers, New England Patriots, these guys win consistently because its expected. And simply 'competing' is beneath them.